Restaurants

Nimrod Inn Bar & Supper Club

4.5 428 reviews Closed N12808 Northway Dr, Athelstane, WI 54104, United States

Discover this place

The Nimrod Inn Bar & Supper Club located in Athelstane, WI, has garnered a loyal following, and for good reason. With a rich history of serving superb meals for over three decades, it’s no surprise that patrons rave about the prime rib, touted as the best in the area by long-time visitor Sean Williams. The restaurant's salad bar and signature chicken gizzards are also crowd favorites, showcasing its commitment to offering hearty and comforting American cuisine.

Newcomers will find themselves pleasantly surprised, as Jean Belanger noted, with generous portions and attentive service that create a welcoming dining experience. The menu doesn't stop at prime cuts; the broiled cod, fried cod, and walleye have also received glowing remarks, indicating that quality is a consistent priority across the board. Jeremy Hanson supports this with accolades for the immaculate setting that strikes a balance between modern and inviting.

Specials like two-for-one drinks during Packer games make it a lively spot for sports fans and those looking to enjoy a casual night out. With great food and a dedicated staff, Nimrod Inn Bar & Supper Club is not just a meal; it’s an experience that keeps customers returning time and again.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Historic
Trendy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Nimrod Inn Bar & Supper Club before visiting.

Reviews for Nimrod Inn Bar & Supper Club

4.5

428 reviews

100%

26%

Review highlights

Based on 428 reviews

Nimrod Inn Bar & Supper Club consistently receives praise for its quality food, particularly its prime rib, steaks, and seafood offerings, which are described as generous in portion and prepared with care. The establishment's atmosphere is noted as clean, updated, and welcoming without being overly formal. Customers frequently highlight the friendly and attentive service, contributing to a comfortable dining experience. The presence of special promotions, such as drink deals during local sporting events, enhances its appeal. Regular patrons appreciate the variety available, including a well-regarded salad bar and diverse menu options. Overall, Nimrod Inn is recognized for maintaining a reliable standard that balances classic supper club charm with contemporary touches, making it a favored spot for both longtime visitors and first-timers seeking hearty, well-executed meals.

Sean Williams

Jul 03, 2025

Still the best prime rib around. The salad bar and chicken gizzards are always a favorite. It's been a while since I've I gotten a pizza here but they were always really good. I've been coming here for 30 years.

Lisa Blade

Jul 02, 2025

Fantastic food. Fantastic staff. Highly recommend Recommend calling in to set a reservation.

Jean Belanger

May 09, 2025

First time eating here and we were pleasantly surprised with the portions, the service and the quality of the food. We will definitely be back. The broiled cod was awesome and the fried cod and walleye were top notch. It's obvious their chef takes pride in his work. Thank You

Jeremy Hanson

May 07, 2025

Loved it. Steaks and prime rib were amazing. Nice, clean and updated, but nothing over the top. Highly recommend.

Brian OConnor

Apr 15, 2025

Great food, great service and 2 4 1 drinks during Packer games!

Abby Champagne

Apr 12, 2025

Love this place! Their salmon dish is soooo delicious! I love their salad bar, too. We will be back!

Jason

Apr 06, 2025

Nimrod's is an excellent bar/ restaurant. Between the bar tenders and the waitstaff, everyone is always polite and courteous. The salad bar is great and the main dishes are second to none. Never been disappointed in 12 years. They also have gizzards!!! Thanks Nimrod's for the good times!

Rebecca Bader

Mar 17, 2025

Had the Sunday family style chicken dinner with salad bar. The whole atmosphere was absolutely amazing. The old fashioneds are great. I got whiskey sour with mushrooms, husband got whiskey sweet with mushrooms. We want to go back to try the prime rib on Saturday. The staff was awesome. Our waitress Alex was so good and sweet. The bartender was super nice and the owners husband chatted with us for awhile. I highly recommend this place.